ImageHeader
  • Home
  • Services
    • Commercial Property Damage Restoration
    • Fire Damage Restoration
    • Water Damage Restoration for Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey
    • Mold Damage Remediation
    • Professional Biohazard Cleanup
    • Emergency Board Up
  • Our Team
  • Customer Reviews
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Report a Loss
  • Contact Us
mold growth in wet Philadelphai PA basement

OP ED: Ethical Mold Remediation and Third Party Testing

Posted by Kristine Allcroft, PhD 
· January 27, 2016 
· No Comments

Buyer beware! In the wild, wild West of mold remediation, few states have laws that govern best practices for the profession.

This post is in response to the thought provoking article by Michael A. Pinto, CSP, CMP, Chief Executive Officer of Wonder Makers Environmental, Inc.

In his article, “Is Quality Control A Conflict of Interest?” Mr. Pinto questions the need and practice for external, third-party verification after mold remediation. He calls into question the “strong suggestion” in the IICRC S520 Standard for Professional Mold Remediation that mold testing done at the end of a job should be done by a company who has no ties to the remediation company. Mr. Pinto calls this suggestion by the IICRC the “hijacking” of an industry.

The question Mr. Pinto raises: Is it really a conflict of interest for a mold remediation company to do their own post-remediation clearance test?

In his article, Mr. Pinto states that it doesn’t make sense to prevent a mold remediation company from checking their own work when a job is completed. He asserts that there is no conflict of interest for a mold remediation company to do their own clearance test. To support this assertion, Mr. Pinto uses an example that “a similar argument about conflict of interest could be made for the surgeon who diagnoses a tumor. Would it make any sense at all to then restrict the doctor who discovered the problem from fixing it?”

Mr. Pinto’s example is a good one. But perhaps not in the way he intends.

Using Mr. Pinto’s example of a person with a tumor, in standard Western medicine the process goes something like this:

  • A person feels “something wrong” and goes to see their family doctor.
  • The doctor examines and makes a preliminary diagnosis. The doctor sends the patient for external, third-party laboratory testing to verify his diagnosis. If the test is positive, the patient is referred to an oncologist.
  • The oncologist examines the patient and performs a biopsy. The biopsy is sent to a third- party pathology lab to confirm whether or not there is a tumor. If positive, the patient is referred to a surgeon.
  • The surgeon examines the patient and sends them to get yet another set of laboratory tests from an objective third- party. This battery of tests usually includes an X-Ray or an MRI both of which are interpreted by a radiologist.
  • Once the surgeon receives the results from the laboratory and the report from the radiologist, surgery is scheduled to remove the tumor.
  • The successful removal of the tumor is then confirmed by yet another set of external, third-party laboratory tests, MRI’s and X-Rays.

In every step of the patient’s care, there is a check and cross-check guiding the physicians’ treatment decisions. Additional layers of oversight are provided by external review boards, as well as the insurance companies who issue the physicians malpractice insurance.

Mr. Pinto’s example actually highlights the precise reasons why mold testing should be performed by an objective, external third-party. As in the medical example, external, third-party pre- and post-remediation verification protects the consumer in two ways: 1. Pre-testing establishes whether or not there is a mold problem that needs remediation; and 2. Post-remediation verification establishes that the consumer got what they paid for.

In the Wild Wild West of mold remediation in the Greater Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey region, any person with a bottle of bleach can call themselves a mold remediator.

We know of too many instances when local companies have exploited their customer’s good faith and put their customer’s health at risk because they are not required by law to follow a standard of care. We know from conversations with our customers that most of these contractors don’t even mention that there is such a thing as pre- and post-remediation mold testing. But the situation in our region is not that unusual.

For a long time there were only two states requiring that mold testing be done by a company different from the company doing the mold remediation. However, in January, 2015 the State of New York  joined Texas  and Florida  enacting legislation to govern the activities of mold remediation and mold testing.

The pertinent part of the New York State legislation as it pertains to Mr. Pinto’s argument reads:
1. No Licensee shall perform both mold assessment and mold remediation on the same property.
2. No person shall own an interest in both the entity which performs mold assessment service and the entity which performs mold remediation services on the same property.

The New York State law has two purposes: To protect the consumer from mold remediation companies who: A. may have less than honorable intents (like a mold removal company who consistently passes their own work even if the work has not been done to the standard); and B. to protect the consumer from companies with less than adequate training and knowledge to correctly complete the job. The laws in all three states have an added benefit for mold contractors: they protect the remediation company from legal issues by providing external oversight that the job was done right.

Mr. Pinto concludes his argument by stating: “You can’t legislate honesty. If you are an honest contractor and have a reputation for such business ethics, there is little risk to the customer if you investigate and remediate, and then even check your own work.”

We agree with Mr. Pinto at least on the first part. You can’t legislate honesty any more than you can legislate compassion.

But you can legislate ethical behavior. Examples of similar regulations abound in professions such as those with fiduciary responsibilities as well as those with health care obligations. Enacting legislation to govern mold remediation and mold testing activities would publicly hold all mold remediation contractors to a standard of care in which the consumer’s and the contractor’s best interest are protected.

At issue is the danger to the consumer if a mold remediation company does either no testing or the wrong kind of test (tape or swab test vs. air sampling tests) to justify a costly remediation job and interprets the test incorrectly at its completion.

The IICRC S520, 3rd edition guides the remediation activities of PuroClean Emergency Recovery Services

In the absence of any current state regulations for Pennsylvania or New Jersey, PuroClean Emergency Recovery Services follows the voluntary recommendations of the IICRC S520 Standard for Professional Mold Remediation.

The IICRC process guidelines define the standard of care and creates a uniformity of outcome that has the consumer’s and the contractor’s best interest at heart.

We educate all our customers and inform them of the guidelines for testing to empower their decisions.

If you have questions about mold remediation in Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey call

877-750-7876

Related Posts

  • mold fact check: Dr. Oz Healthy Home InvestigationMold Fact Check: Dr. Oz Healthy Home Investigation
  • For Philadelphia & South Jersey: How to choose a mold inspector for your homeFor Philadelphia & South Jersey: How to choose a mold inspector for your home
  • Mold Exposure: Not the usual suspects!Mold Exposure: Not the usual suspects!
  • Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey water damage and mold damageHonesty, Integrity and Mold Damage Remediation
  • 7 Ways You know Your Inbound Marketing Campaign Is A Success7 Ways You know Your Inbound Marketing Campaign Is A Success
  • Bristol PA: Clean water lossCan I save my carpet and pad after a flood?
  • Post Construction Mold Is A Growing Problem
  • Fire Damage Cleanup in Aisle Four!
  • Don’t Do These 11 Things If You Have A Kitchen Grease Fire
  • burst braided metal hose water damageBusting The Myth of Indestructibility: Burst Braided Metal Hose Supply Lines
  • preventing winter water damage on Groundhog dayHappy Groundhog Day!
  • Frozen Gutters, Ice Dams:  The biggest threat to your home right now!Frozen Gutters, Ice Dams: The biggest threat to your home right now!

Share this:

  • Tweet
No Comments
Categories : Mold Inspection & Removal, Mold removal New Jersey, Mold removal Philadelphia
Tags : mold remediation, mold removal guidelines, mold removal standards
Previous Post →
← Next Post

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Recent Posts from the Blog

30 Tips To Get Your Home Ready For Winter!

December 12, 2017
30 Tips To Get Your Home Ready For Winter!: Are you ready for winter? Here are the top 30 tips to get your home ready PLUS 10 ways to reduce energy costs. Learn more!

Top 30 Tips To Get Your Home Ready For Winter! Winter is just around the corner and in some places has already arrived. PuroClean is proud to serve consumers and business owners in the Philadelphia and Southern NJ areas. One of our goals is to educate and inform our visitors about mold, fire, water, bio-hazard, […]

Read article →

Why Do Christmas Trees Cause Illness?

November 28, 2017
Why Do Christmas Trees Cause Illness?: Do you get sick soon after your Christmas tree is in the home? This article explains why. We also provide you with 8 Xmas tree fire safety tips. Learn more!

Your Christmas Tree Is Not Only A Fire Hazard, But Can Also Make You Sick From Mold! PuroClean is dedicated to informing our customers about mold and the health related concerns it causes. We are also passionate about fire prevention, which is particularly important during the holiday season because of the fire hazards posed by […]

Read article →

Top 10 Tips To Prevent Electrical Fires!

November 14, 2017
Top 10 Tips To Prevent Electrical Fires!: This article give you 10 tips to prevent electrical fires. Plus, we explain how a thermal imaging inspection could identify potential electrical problems!

Ten Tips To Prevent Electrical Fires, The 2nd Largest Cause! One of the core services that PuroClean offers to residents in Philadelphia and Southern NJ is fire and smoke restoration. Our team has helped many home and business owners restore their properties after experiencing a fire or smoke event. PuroClean has so many satisfied customers […]

Read article →

How to Avoid A Clothes Dryer Fire?

October 31, 2017
How to Avoid a Dryer Fire?: Did you know that approximately 15,500 fires are started by clothes dryers each year? This article explains why dirty dryer ducts are a fire hazard and what you can do to protect you and your family.

What Is The Number One Reason Clothes Dryers Are A Fire Hazard? One of the core services that PuroClean offers to residents in Philadelphia and Southern NJ is fire and smoke restoration. Our team has helped many home and business owners restore their properties after experiencing a fire or smoke event. PuroClean has so many […]

Read article →

Concerned About Mold In Schools?

October 17, 2017
Concerned About Mold In Schools?: There have been several high profile stories about mold in schools in Philadelphia and Southern NJ. If you have questions, we have answers!

Got Questions About Mold In Schools? We Have Answers! “Once school started again, he was having breathing issues; he didn’t have any issues over the summer. This is their health and they have to breathe this in. Every single day that they are there, six hours a day that they are at school. I don’t […]

Read article →
PuroClean Emergency Recovery Services
For Immediate 24/7 Response in the Greater Philadelphia and Southern NJ Region, Call 877-750-7876.
Services: Commercial Property Damage Restoration · Fire Damage Restoration · Water Damage Restoration
Mold Damage Remediation · Professional Biohazard Cleanup · Emergency Board Up
Our Team · Customer Reviews · Frequently Asked Questions · Report a Loss · Contact Us
Copyright © 2011-2022 by PuroClean Emergency Recovery Services. All Rights Reserved.
Site Credits